Golden Melody Awards Results
June 28th, 2009Well, yesterday was the big day for the Golden Melody Awards, and now I have a new theory. I’ve actually seen variations of this from assorted news commentary sites for the last few weeks and am just joining a (growing) crowd. The idea is that given the overall deterioration in the quality of Jay’s work, the GMA judges must have thought it a last chance to give him the overdue best Male Mandarin Artist award before the notion of Jay as one of the best Mandarin artists has grown utterly absurd.
The thing is, the idea that Jay has never won this award *is* pretty ridiculous, as he has for years reigned as the undisputed king of Mandopop, and whatever his failings as a singer, he has a history of excellent compositions. At the same time, though, the idea of him winning the honor on the basis of this latest album is equally ridiculous, as it is so far away from his best work. As a friend noted yesterday, though, it’s like finally giving the Oscar to Al Pacino for Scent of a Woman - it feels more like a remedy for the oversight in the Godfather era than an independently earned honor.
I don’t buy the idea of “Fragrant Rice (稻香)” as the best Mandopop song of last year, but it is far less offensive than many of the other tracks on that album, and even a marked improvement over some other past picks (”Today I Marry You” with Jolin Tsai and David Tao springs instantly to mind). Moreover, the theme of soldiering on through tough economic times that comes out most clearly in the video is obviously quite relevant, though of course the video should have no real relevance on the judgment of the song. Most importantly, though, the GMA judges did not debase themselves to the extent of actually claiming Capricorn was the album of the year, which I confess had worried me.
Anyway, here are the winners (skipping again the Taiwanese, Hakka and other similar categories that I just don’t follow). (For reference, my post on the nominees is here.)
Song of the year: “Fragrant Rice,” Jay Chou
Mandarin album of the Year: Don’t Want to Let Go, Eason Chan
Video of the year: “Mr. Magician,” directed by Jay Chou
Best Composition: Crowd Lu, “100 Ways of Living”
Best Lyrics: Wu Yuxuan, “In the Trollycar”
Best Arrangement: Martin Tan, “As Love Begins to Mend”
Best Album Production:Chen Jiannian, Nanwan Sisters Self-Titled Album
Best Produced Single:Wang Zhiping, Guo Wenzhong “Gaze”
Best Male Mandarin Singer: Jay Chou, Capricorn
Best Female Mandarin Singer: Sandee Chan, If One Thing Is Most Important
Best Band: Mayday, Poetry of the Day After
Best Performing Group: Nanwan Sisters, Nanwan Sisters Self-titled Album
Best Newcomer: Crowd Lu, 100 Ways of Living
The lyrics prize is actually my greatest disappointment in these results. A lyricist award for Ashin is just as overdue as the best male artist award for Jay. I did worry that being nominated for two songs would split the vote for him, though, and I can’t help but think that could have happened here.
Now I’m back in the US for a while and soon, I hope, will even have regular internet access, so I should be back to much more regular posting soon.
